Homes for Sale in Innisfil $500K - $750K

Explore our selection of properties in Innisfil priced $500K - $750K. Known for Lake Simcoe access, Innisfil offers cottage-style living near Barrie. The Battaglia Team provides expert guidance to find your perfect home in this lakeside community.

210 listings available

210 properties found

Detached

1104 Ferrier Avenue, Innisfil

211,100 sqft

$550,000

Townhouse

1154 Inniswood Street, Innisfil

321,100 sqft

$524,900

Townhouse

1137 Stantin Street, Innisfil

351,100 sqft

$598,888

Condo

233 Broward Way Unit 10, Innisfil

231,000 sqft

$649,000

Detached

1292 Vincent Crescent, Innisfil

331,100 sqft

$676,000

Detached

972 Gilmore Avenue, Innisfil

21700 sqft

$519,000

Townhouse

17 Ravenscraig Place, Innisfil

331,100 sqft

$649,900

Detached

1147 Belle Aire Beach Road, Innisfil

521,100 sqft

$699,900

Detached

1207 Andrade Lane, Innisfil

331,500 sqft

$674,900

Detached

3816 30th Side Road, Innisfil

21700 sqft

$639,900

Detached

1061 2nd Line, Innisfil

21700 sqft

$549,900

Detached

3923 Algonquin Avenue, Innisfil

321,500 sqft

$729,999

Townhouse

1403 BENSON Street, Innisfil

331,100 sqft

$629,900

New Construction

2259 Grainger Loop N/A, Innisfil

331,500 sqft

$599,000

Townhouse

1486 Purchase Place, Innisfil

332,000 sqft

$669,998

Townhouse

1280 Coleman Crescent, Innisfil

331,500 sqft

$649,000

Townhouse

719 Sargeant Place, Innisfil

231,500 sqft

$538,900

Condo

241 Sea Ray Avenue Unit A213, Innisfil

22800 sqft

$514,900

Detached

1031 Ferrier Avenue, Innisfil

311,100 sqft

$629,000

Detached

1805 ST JOHN'S Road, Innisfil

31700 sqft

$719,500

Condo

333 Sea Ray Avenue Unit D322, Innisfil

22800 sqft

$529,900

Townhouse

1768 Lamstone Street, Innisfil

331,100 sqft

$699,999

Detached

17 Church Street, Innisfil

311,100 sqft

$650,000

Detached

19 Hearts Content N/A, Innisfil

221,100 sqft

$510,000

Page 1 of 9

About Homes in Innisfil

Innisfil is one of the GTA's lakeside communities, defined by its Lake Simcoe access and cottage-style living near Barrie. The Innisfil market includes everything from condo apartments and townhomes to detached homes on mature lots — with the right property type depending on your stage of life, household size, and long-term plans. Buyers drawn to Innisfil typically value its proximity to major transit corridors, established school catchments, and the lakeside character that distinguishes it from neighbouring municipalities.

Who's Buying $500K - $750K Homes in Innisfil

Properties priced $500k - $750k in Innisfil attract growing families, professionals upgrading from a starter, and those relocating from higher-cost areas. At this price point, expect roughly $2,800–$4,200 in monthly carrying costs (mortgage, taxes, insurance) with 20% down at current rates. This is the most competitive price segment in the GTA — homes presented well sell within 7–14 days year-round.

Working with the Battaglia Team in Innisfil

The Battaglia Team has been serving Innisfil and the surrounding GTA since 1995. We pair MLS listings (refreshed every few hours from the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board) with hyper-local market knowledge: school boundary changes, planned infrastructure, neighbourhood-specific buyer competition, and recent comparable sales not visible on public portals. Whether you're touring your first home or making a strategic move into Innisfil's $500k - $750k market, our team handles MLS searches, virtual previews, in-person showings, offer strategy, and negotiation end-to-end. Reach out for a no-obligation conversation about your goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do homes cost in Innisfil $500k - $750k?

Pricing for homes in Innisfil varies by neighbourhood, lot size, age of the property, and current market conditions. Within the $500k - $750k band, listings typically reflect the lakeside character of the area and proximity to Lake Simcoe access. For an up-to-the-minute price snapshot tied to your specific needs, contact the Battaglia Team for a free comparative market analysis.

What should I know before buying a home in Innisfil?

Innisfil is known for Lake Simcoe access and cottage-style living near Barrie. Before making an offer, review the property's status certificate (for condos), arrange a pre-listing inspection where possible, and confirm school catchment if you have children. Property taxes in Innisfil are calculated on assessed value (MPAC) and vary by ward — your agent can pull the exact figure for any address.

What down payment do I need for a $500k - $750k home?

At this price point, expect roughly $2,800–$4,200 in monthly carrying costs (mortgage, taxes, insurance) with 20% down at current rates.

How quickly do homes sell in Innisfil?

Time-on-market in Innisfil varies by season, price range, and presentation quality. Well-priced, well-staged listings in the entry-level bands typically attract serious offers within 7–21 days. Luxury listings ($1.5M+) can take 30–90 days. Reach out for a current market velocity report for Innisfil.